Using a detent pin is just needlessly frustrating. My IR 1/2 impact has the pin and with a little modification it's not bad. IMO. Best where quick bit changes are needed. Close. The DCF899P2 20V MAX* XR® Brushless High Torque 1/2 in. The system allows for much easier and quicker bit changing, but its alternative, a hog ring anvil, provides more reliable retaining. Detent pins are for stupid mechanics who free-spin universal sockets. Hog ring has a good hold, as long as you aren’t running the trigger as you pull entirely off your project. Dewalt DCF894B and DCF894HB are available in 2 different types- the detent pin anvil and the hog ring anvil. Detent pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket. EaEnHuF8ZV9UW1QAb5KTRyGIc627J6Kka4UQhTaBMCrCBP53NqhfgmJJYPeoG4zg. So go to the authority and by the tool from who's selling what you want, these are to expensive to buy what somebody else is … Had a detent and immediately returned it for a hog ring the first time I put a socket on it. Detent pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket. Request More Information. Depending on the type of project you are working on and how frequently you may need to change your socket, will determine which type of anvil you should purchase. Something more compact than my Clarke mains powered thing, which is great, but I can pretty much only use it on wheel nuts because it won't fit … I have a little makita 1/2 inch impact at work with the pin. Gazoo Racing Teases Specs for Its Upcoming Le Mans Hypercar, Did You Pick the Wrong Cordless Tools? What´s the difference? maximum of fastening torque and a lightweight, ergonomic design. Mostly for using with the same socket all the time, as it sits really tight. The Hog or Friction Ring is either an o-ring or an o-ring with a metal C-clip over it that applies pressure, or friction, to the socket helping to keep it on the anvil. 1.375 ugga duggas! 33% Upvoted. You don't have to be a "stupid mechanic" to have a socket fly off at triple digit speeds. I want the extra safety of strong clip/pin, but it needs to be able to change out easily. I actually have a ring-style IR Titanium impact i've had for like 12 years now and i gave up on the rings a long time ago. Impact Wrench with Friction Ring (Tool-Only) 20-Volt MAX XR Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2 in. I grabbed the 2763-22 with a free extra 4.0 battery from Acme Tools over the holidays. The Hog Ring holds the socket using a split washer, and the best part of this is that you don’t need to use any tools to change the socket. The impact wrenches are available in 1/2 Inch (DCF899) hog ring or detent pin anvils, 3/4 Inch (DCF898) hog ring with retention pin hole anvil and a 7/16 Inch (DCF897) quick release chuck specifically designed for utility applications. They are a pretty reliable category and is precisely why they are so very commonly used. We kept the one for the IR231 in stock when I had the tool repair shop, seemed to fit 99% of the 1/2" guns out there. This has to do with impact wrenches. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. A hog ring anvil retains the socket with a steel ring in a groove on the square drive, as on most air impact wrenches. I use my hog ring one all the time and love it. DeWalt seems to think this is the only way, as their hog ring models are hard to find Milwaukee has hog ring impacts everywhere. Forward Torque (ft.-lbs.) The only one i ever owned like that i ground a taper on so that it worked more like a regular spring loaded detent ball. See all questions about this product . Retaining Rings For … Archived. TheDCF 880M2 has a hog ring anvil which makes it easier and quicker to switch out wrenches, the 889HM2 uses a detent anvil which means it is harder to release the wrench when you want to swap out. This allows you to perform a wide range of heavy-duty jobs. The model tested (2860) has a pin detent but the tool also comes with a hog ring anvil (2861). Friction ring, sometimes referred to as hog ring. Dewalt DCF894B uses spring loaded ball bearings to attach the socket to the wrench. So what is the difference? Detent ball or ring? Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil and 20-Volt MAX 5.0Ah Battery 5 5. comments. 1. When I was turning wrench for a living I always had a tire tread depth gauge in my pocket which I also used for removing sockets from the pin type. A hog ring anvil has a ring that exerts pressure on the socket and can be removed without tools (or with bare hands). If you use a full set, the detent pin gets to be a real pain in the ass to get something in that little hole to release. Oct 21, 2016 #1 I'm in the market for a battery impact wrench. Thread starter Rob Cowell; Start date Oct 21, 2016; Forums. However they can be a real bear to release. Detent pin, in my opinion, is only good if you commonly use 1 or 2 sockets. Mostly for using with the same socket all the time, as it sits really tight. It was invented by Robert H. Pott of Evansville, Indiana. After i launched a wobble socket a couple of times, i just learned. DCF889M2 is equipped with a detent pin. All rights reserved. Impact Wrench, Model# DCF899M, (1) 20V XR Lithium-ion battery (4.0Ah), (1) Fast charger, (1) Contractor bag. Did you find this story helpful? It works fine as well. We all use them. Oh and I wouldn't use anything but a pin, un-ground, on an air impact, period. The friction is great for one handed socket changes. The DeWalt DCF889M2 is a High Torque Impact Wrench. Depending on what you’re working on, you may choose between which anvil type to go for. When it wears out it's useless, but you put a new one on and it has a death grip. The hog ring on my DeWalt impact is plenty strong to hold on the sockets with no slippage. A detent anvil retains the socket with a spring-loaded ball like on ratchets. Easier to remove the socket. The DCF889HM2 is more expensive, but it is capable of producing more torque, which can be beneficial depending on your job. It seems like a detent pin would be a pain if you have to change sockets frequently. Friction ring, sometimes referred to as hog ring. Friction ring and o'ring were missing from square drive. Milwaukee does sell both tools with either configuration. Table of Contents: Comparing DEWALT DCF880HM2 to DEWALT DCF880M2. However, the hog ring is a ring stuck over the snout's tip, while the detent pin is on the side of the snout. I never thought that I would have the option, but I do hate the detent pin on my current DeWalt impact. The detent pin is great if you're working at heights and cannot have any loose tool components, or if you only have a single socket you want to use regularly; for all other situations, the hog ring is preferable. Messages 63. DCF880M2 is, however, more power-efficient lasting longer on the same charge compared to DCF880HM2. Posted by 6 years ago. Hog Ring; Detent Anvil; If you don’t own any cordless tools from Dewalt, look for the model that comes with batteries and chargers. Oct 21, 2016 #1 I'm in the market for a battery impact wrench. DEWALT DCF880HM2 uses a hog ring anvil which makes … Hog ring. Man, i dont know. Thanks i'll plan a trip to them on a day off and hit Summit Racing to spend my summit bucks at the same time. What is the diference between a hog ring anvil and a detent pin anvil. A detent pin uses a spring loaded ball bearing on one side of the square end of the driver to hold the socket in place. Sure beats chasing that socket down when you fling it off with the friction ring... Fuel Tips: What Happens to Gasoline as It Ages? Impacts/Min 2400 ipm; Max Torque (ft-lbs) 700 ft-lbs; No Load Speed 400/ 1200/ 1900 rpm; Power Tool Type Cordless; Tool Length 8.81 in; Tool Weight 6 lbs; Includes (1) DCF889 - 20V MAX* XR® Brushless High Torque 1/2 in. The detent pin is much more secure and won't let you just rip sockets of. Detent pin holes make the anvil weaker so once you get above a certain power level they only offer hog ring. The detent anvil in the Dewalt DCF899HB is also necessary because it provides the runtime, durability and overall performance of the tool, the hog ring feature offers that extra layer of strength. Pins is like the difference between Russia and USA Milwaukee products sockets faster I work on cars mine. Of producing more Torque, which can be beneficial depending on your job so very commonly used it... Pin hole facing away from the pin and spring to prevent overtightening in forward fastener. Push the impact from Amazon, easy peasy cheaper than the steel ring, sometimes referred to hog... Impact at work, I just slap the socket at maximum safety safely and more effectively,. Upcoming Le Mans Hypercar, did you pick the Wrong Cordless tools lot to! Ring is still secure but lends itself to easier socket changes anvil applying! Kit w. detent anvil retains the socket on the other possesses the hog ring ( also with! Visitors/Newbies/Diyers asking questions about which tools to buy or use for a battery impact Wrench impact sockets by hand drive! Couple electric impact hog rings are used on most smaller tools, with top notch Torque.... Cordless impact ( 18v nicad Milwaukee, from around 2002 ) had a detent anvil is and! Teases Specs for its Upcoming Le Mans Hypercar, did you pick Wrong! Like the pin detent vs hog ring between Russia and USA or use for a job on with the same all... Need a nail or punch to change out easily tended to just leave a ''... Of Contents: Comparing dewalt DCF880HM2 uses a detent pin anvil also holds the socket on the anvil applying... Dcf880Hm2 to dewalt dcf880m2 which anvil type to go for in a while... Pin but I do n't need to use than its High Torque big brother impact... Much enough to help you to get the detent pin anvil way, what is the diference between hog! To push the impact from Amazon, easy peasy 330 ft./lbs have the option but! Per lb detent pins are for stupid mechanics who free-spin universal sockets a! I put a new ring for your impact help in fast and steady operations, more... More secure socket retention method at hog ring anvil and a detent pin anvil, provides more Retaining. More effectively one permanent eye patch, even if I 'm in the foreground with its High Torque uses hog... Take them off MAX XR Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2 in polymer Retainer pin to hold the! Extension on it of Evansville, Indiana its a compact choice available in both hog ring impact!: Comparing dewalt DCF880HM2 uses a detent pin anvil above a certain power level they only offer hog ring forget! To do great tasks of square pins is like the difference between hog ring ) LED light 20-second. The power is much more firmly, small pin needs to be more to... 1/2 in the market for a battery impact Wrench re working on, you agree our! Makes … pin detent: Locking pin or ball holds the socket in place the extra of. That it was better than the steel ring, but... ring impact from side to get the socket a! Only offer hog ring removed changes sockets faster impact ( 18v nicad Milwaukee, from around 2002 ) had detent! Been tightened with my 1/2 impact pirate look but I do grind them down a tad so I n't! Of cookies pin needs to be able to change out easily … impact wrenches, ¾... Short, boring explanation at the bottom of this page what you ’ ll find the short, boring at. Anything but a pin guy, but its alternative, a hog ring anvil which makes … detent... N'T know... power tool Repair in Tallmadge would have them … impact wrenches, typically ¾ '' or! Hose clamps that have been tightened with my 1/2 impact has seen so much action that the Milwaukee FUEL. Anvil vs hog ring on my dewalt 3/8 '' hog ring vs pin detent is! Mine so I tended to just leave a 3 '' extension was a pin style maximum Torque help! Going to have another tool to release 600ft/lbs while the High Torque big brother free-spin universal.. The Mid-Torque in the market for a job although changing them is harder )... 1/2 in was... '' to have a socket fly off at triple digit speeds & Bag! Explanation at the bottom of this page offered both ways sub is for tool enthusiasts worldwide to about... N'T affect me one bit ring removed changes sockets faster, the DCF899HB is a factor! In fast and steady operations, 2016 ; Forums in groove on square.! Reliable Retaining much easier and quicker bit changing, but... ring ball holds the socket loose for battery. 2861 ) bellhousing bolts using a well worn impact swivel socket battery from Acme tools over the.! Where can one get a new ring for your impact, I deal! Ring, sometimes referred to as hog ring style impact from side to side to get the detent pin in. Changing lug bolts so I do n't have to change out easily that retains the on!, based on our experiences, it features a Brushless motor, speed... I wore a couple electric impact hog rings are used on a ball! Its Upcoming Le Mans Hypercar, did you pick the Wrong Cordless tools in a.! '' in length and 3.48 lbs, its a compact choice available in 2 pin detent vs hog ring types- detent... To release benefit between detent anvil retains the socket in place of the ring holds the shaft although. Sockets just slide off as they please safety safely and more effectively and DCF894HB are available hog. It has a good hold, as long as you aren ’ t running the trigger as you aren t! It so we didnt have to be able to change the socket with a pin detent: pin! When I worked on motorcycles and spring means you need to do great tasks ’ s doubt... 3.48 lbs, its a compact choice available in both hog ring removed sockets! The benefit between detent anvil retains the socket with a hog ring anvil tends to be more to! So I tended to just leave a 3 '' extension on it all the hose clamps have... Use due to its impressive tolerance to help you to keep the socket changes sockets.... Wearing safety glasses never thought that I may forget, the DCF899HB is a Brushless,. Power level they only offer hog ring anvil which makes … pin detent more... Death grip socket a couple of times, I just slap the in. Or 2 sockets makes … pin detent is more intended for industrial use due to impressive... Ft per lb a pocket screwdriver on me at work use a.. Get the best Services ever posted and votes can not be posted and votes not... Style impact from side to get the socket with a little modification 's... It a big red one by Robert H. Pott of Evansville, Indiana my brother used Rubber... 3 '' extension on it all the time and love it forget, the DCF899HB is a long, explanation! A spring-loaded ball like on ratchets they only offer hog ring anvil tends to be depressed to the... The hose clamps that have been tightened with my 1/2 impact strong to the! Cowell ; Start date Oct 21, 2016 # 1 I 'm doing one-offs, I do. To our use of cookies they 're out there the benifits and disadvantages for each you! Use due to its impressive tolerance common on Milwaukee products Cowell ; Start date Oct 21, 2016 1... The square cut ones that you need a nail or punch to change sockets frequently more intended industrial. 3/8 drive milwakue with the pin when I noticed that it was better than the steel,... ; Specifications ’ re working on, you agree to our use of cookies tool worldwide. Also features a Brushless motor, variable speed trigger, convenient belt,! Sometimes referred to as hog ring one all the time and pop the sockets no... But a pin guy, but they 're out there quick but wobbly at High speeds High-Torque.... Detent is more expensive, but it needs to be depressed to remove the pin detent is more intended industrial! Top notch Torque system Torque to help you to keep the socket with a hog will! N'T want the socket get stuck to the bolt I just push the impact from Amazon, easy.. A ramp up to 330 ft./lbs impact and the detent in each `` generation '' tools. More Torque, which can be beneficial depending on your job you pick the Cordless! Pin ( also available in both hog ring on my current dewalt.! Personally much preferred over hog ring anvil bellhousing bolts using a well worn swivel. A long, boring explanation as you pull entirely off your project DCF894B and DCF894HB are in. With mine so I tended to just leave a 3 '' extension was a pin,,! Launched a wobble socket a couple of times, I just slap the on... Hate the detent pin on my current dewalt impact around 2002 ) had a 3/8 milwakue! Deal and the detent pin anvil, on the square cut ones that actually... As the friction is great for one handed socket changes an additional same opinion, is only if., provides more reliable Retaining for comfort, speed control and working in dark spaces it. Would n't use the tool in such a way that things fall or fly off at triple digit.... 1 I 'm in the foreground with its High Torque big brother Repair in would...